Emergency Steps When a Business Partner Is Destroying Your Business

TL;DR

If your business partner is about to take control, shut you out of a vote, shrink your ownership, compete with the company, or strip its assets, a New York court can stop your partner while the case goes on, but only if you act quickly, have strong documents, and can show that money would not fix the harm later. A TRO can freeze things within days, and a preliminary injunction can keep them frozen until the case ends. Expect a bond requirement and around $10,000 in fees for the initial filing, and remember that losing an emergency request can hurt the rest of your case.

When a co-owner goes rogue, damage control cannot wait for a lawsuit to run its course. If your partner is about to lock you out, vote you off the board, or hand your shares to someone else, a ruling two years from now comes too late.

You do not always have to wait that long. When I file a lawsuit against your partner, I can also ask the judge for an order that stops your partner right away and keeps things as they are while the case goes on.

I handle emergency motions in business disputes regularly. If your situation is urgent, call me at 212-253-1027 or contact me here. The initial consultation is free, and I can usually tell you quickly whether emergency relief is realistic in your situation.

What a TRO and Preliminary Injunction Are

To get an emergency order, you first have to sue your partner, so I usually file the lawsuit and the emergency request on the same day. The lawsuit starts with a summons, which notifies your partner that you are suing, and a complaint, which is a sworn statement of what your partner did and what you want the court to do about it.

In plain terms, the request would ask the judge to please stop your partner from doing what he or she is doing while the case goes through the regular track (slow) litigation. The request includes papers that show why the feared actions have all the requirements needed for such request (described below) and asks the judge to give your partner a few weeks to officially respond. This requested “please order the other side to stop” order is called a preliminary injunction. The judge decides whether to grant it only after both sides have submitted their full package of papers, one package in support and one package in opposition, and if the judge grants it, the order would last until the lawsuit ends, at trial or in a settlement.

Sometimes the harm might happen before the preliminary injunction is decided which usually takes weeks or months. In that case, the request adds a second, more urgent ask, which is that while your partner prepares the response package, the judge signs an order right away stopping your partner in the meantime, because the situation cannot wait. That order is called a temporary restraining order, or TRO. The judge decides whether to sign it from the papers alone, often before your partner has said a word, and it usually lasts only until the judge rules on the preliminary injunction. If the judge refuses the TRO, the request for a preliminary injunction still goes forward, and your partner is simply free to act until the judge rules.

The Three Requirements for a Preliminary Injunction in New York

To get a preliminary injunction in New York, you have to show that you are likely to win the case, that you will suffer irreparable harm without the order, and that stopping your partner would hurt your partner less than letting your partner continue would hurt you, which courts call the balance of the equities.

New York courts require clear and convincing evidence that you are likely to win. If the facts are genuinely disputed, this is harder to show, but a dispute does not end the request on its own. The judge can weigh the documents, hold a hearing where witnesses testify in person, and make an early call on who is more believable.

The second requirement, irreparable harm, turns on whether money could fix the problem later. If money can fix it, you will usually not get the order. If your partner drains $200,000 from the company account, that is terrible, but at the end of the case a court can order your partner to pay it back unless it also means the business has to shut down because of it.

Irreparable harm can take many forms, but in fights between business owners, New York courts have often found it in the following situations:

  • Losing control of the business. If your co-owner calls a meeting to take over the company while the two of you are still disputing who owns what, a court can stop the meeting.
  • Being shut out of a vote. If your partner calls a shareholder meeting without the notice that the law or the bylaws require, you may not be able to attend, and you could lose your board seat or your job as an officer at that meeting. New York treats a shareholder’s right to vote as a property right, and decisions made at an improperly called meeting can be thrown out, so courts will block the meeting beforehand.
  • A manager who has been removed but keeps acting for the company, signing deals and giving orders. Courts have found irreparable harm when a business, particularly one that owns real estate, is still being run by someone the owners voted out.
  • A partner who competes with the business. If your co-owner opens a rival company, takes your customers and employees along, or uses the company’s confidential information to undercut it, the lost clients and goodwill are hard to measure in dollars and, in a small company, can be enough to put it out of business. New York courts can order a partner to stop competing while the case goes on, particularly when the operating agreement or shareholder agreement bars competition or the partner is using the company’s own trade secrets.
  • A partner who diverts the company’s assets. Money taken from the company can usually be repaid, as noted above, but the analysis changes when your partner is moving contracts, equipment, intellectual property, or cash to another entity so quickly that the business will not survive until trial. Courts have found irreparable harm when a partner’s conduct threatens to destroy the business itself, because a judgment at the end of the case means little if there is no company left, and also when the partner is likely to hide or spend the money so that a judgment could never be collected.

Whatever form the harm takes, the judge also has to be convinced that it is real and likely to happen, either because your partner is about to act or because your partner has already done it and is likely to do it again. The possibility that your partner might do something damaging someday will not be enough.

For the balance of the equities, the judge compares what each side stands to lose if the order is granted or denied. An order that only stops your partner from doing something out of the ordinary, such as selling assets, moving money, or calling a surprise vote, costs your partner little while protecting your ownership or your say in the company, so the balance usually tips your way. An order that would shut down operations, freeze the accounts the business needs to pay its bills, or push a co-owner out of a company he or she runs every day costs your partner far more, and the judge will grant it only if what you stand to lose is greater still.

Because the judge has to take sides before hearing all the evidence, meeting all three requirements is hard, and judges grant these orders only when the case for them is strong.

Why Timing Matters When Seeking an Injunction Against a Business Partner

It is important to go to court quickly after the situation becomes dire. Courts are far more willing to stop harmful conduct before it happens than to undo it afterward, and waiting makes a judge doubt that the situation is really an emergency.

Suppose your partner signs a contract to sell the building the company operates from to a friend, without the consent your agreement requires. If you go to court before the sale closes, the judge only has to put the sale on hold. If the sale has already closed by the time you get to court, you would need something different, an order telling your partner to actively do something, in this case to get the building back, rather than an order telling your partner to stop. Lawyers call this a mandatory injunction. Courts can issue these orders, but they are even harder to get than an ordinary injunction, and judges grant them only in unusual cases where your right to the relief is very clear. Keeping things as they are is what judges care about most at this stage, so an order that would change who runs the company, or bring back rights that have already been taken away, faces that higher bar, and you may have to wait for trial even though you are likely right.

Delay also hurts your credibility, since a judge will want to know why you did not come to court sooner if the harm was that serious. A problem that has been building for months may feel urgent the day you finally run out of patience, but a judge will probably not treat it as an emergency.

How to Get a TRO and Preliminary Injunction in New York

If the problem is serious but can wait a few weeks, I ask only for a preliminary injunction. I add a request for a TRO when the harm would happen before the judge could hold a hearing. I do not ask for a TRO just because the matter feels urgent. Judges notice when a TRO is requested for something that could have waited, and it costs credibility later. New York court rules also generally require giving your partner advance notice that you will be asking for a TRO, unless notice itself would cause serious harm (for example, by tipping your partner off to move money first).

If you ask for a TRO, the papers usually go to the judge assigned to your case. If that judge is not available, for example because you file on a weekend or after hours, they go to an emergency judge. Either judge may sign the TRO on the papers alone or may want to hear from both sides first, depending on the judge and the county.

A preliminary injunction request is supposed to be decided promptly, but New York judges carry heavy caseloads, and even after the hearing the motion can sit with the judge for months while it waits its turn. In the meantime, the judge may extend the TRO or let it expire.

Bond Requirements for a Preliminary Injunction in New York

If you get a preliminary injunction, New York law requires you to post a bond, called an undertaking. A bond is a guarantee that money will be there to compensate your partner if the order turns out to have been a mistake. You can post it by depositing cash with the court, but more often you buy it from an insurance or surety company, which charges a fee, usually a small percentage of the bond amount, and may ask for collateral. If the court later decides the order should not have been granted, your partner can collect from the bond for the losses the order caused. The amount depends on how much the order could hurt your partner, and when an order freezes accounts or stops someone from running a business, it can be large. If you cannot post the bond, you do not get the order, however strong your case. A TRO can require a bond too, and while judges sometimes waive it for very short orders, you should not assume they will.

Legal Fees for a TRO and Preliminary Injunction

A lawsuit without an emergency request usually starts with a summons and complaint, and at my firm, preparing those typically costs around $5,000 in legal fees (depending on the complexity of the case, could also be lower). Adding a request for a TRO and a preliminary injunction usually brings the cost of the initial filing to around $10,000, because the judge has to be persuaded right away, on paper, before your partner has said a word. Before I can write those papers, I have to get a firm understanding of all the evidence, which means going through your documents, emails, and records, figuring out what they prove, and organizing them so the judge can follow the story quickly.

Besides the summons and complaint, persuading the judge on paper takes several more documents, starting with the request itself, which sets out exactly what you want the judge to stop and asks the judge to set a date for your partner to respond. It is supported by one or more sworn statements, usually from you and sometimes from employees or others with firsthand knowledge, that tell the story in detail and attach the key emails, bank records, operating agreement, and other documents as exhibits. A memorandum of law explains why the facts meet each of the three requirements described above, citing the legal cases that support you. If you are asking for a TRO, a separate sworn statement from me explains why the matter cannot wait for a hearing and whether and how your partner was told about the request.

How to Fight a TRO Your Business Partner Obtained

You may also be the one served with a TRO. Your partner gets one signed without telling you, and you find yourself locked out of your own business or with your accounts frozen. Even if you think the order is unfair, you have to obey it until a court changes it, because a court order is serious business, and if you violate it, the judge can hold you in contempt and sanction you with fines or an order to pay your partner’s legal fees.

Your first step would be to respond by the date the court set and fight the preliminary injunction. If the TRO is doing serious damage and you cannot wait that long, New York law lets you go straight to the higher court, called the Appellate Division, and ask a judge there to cancel or narrow the TRO. Appeals judges can act within a day or two, but they are reluctant to overrule the trial judge based on papers alone.

When to Seek Emergency Relief Against a Business Partner

Emergency orders make the most sense when the harm is happening now, money will not fix it later, and you can prove it with documents such as bank records of wire transfers, emails showing your partner steering clients away, or evidence of deleted files and changed passwords, rather than suspicions alone.

It also helps to think carefully about how much to ask for. It is common to ask for more than you expect to get, because judges often cross out the parts of the proposed order they are not willing to grant and sign the rest. But the core of the request should be something the judge can comfortably give you. An order barring your partner from making unusual transfers or large expenditures is much easier to justify than one removing your partner as manager or unwinding a deal that has already closed, and a request that reaches too far can make the whole application look overreaching.

If you ask and lose, you start the case in front of a judge who has already found your side unconvincing. Your partner has then seen your best evidence, and you have paid for emergency motion work that did not succeed, so even though the case goes on, you begin it at a disadvantage. For that reason, I do not like bringing an emergency request when I think the chances of winning it are low. Losing it would mean starting the lawsuit with one strike already against us. If your evidence is not strong, you are usually better off skipping the emergency request and building the case for trial.

Before filing, we should look honestly at whether you can meet this standard. If you can, we should move fast, and if you probably cannot, we can file the lawsuit without an emergency request and focus on building the strongest possible case for trial.